SUBMASTERS Menu (Update 2025)
Welcome to SUBMASTERS, a culinary gem located at 105 Main St, North Tonawanda, NY. This restaurant specializes in hearty subs, with each bite delivering big flavor and generous portions that leave patrons raving.
The standout dishes include the mouthwatering grinder sub and the surprisingly light steak sub, both praised for their freshness. For those craving something unique, the pickle pizza is a must-try, combining innovative flavors with classic favorites. Don't overlook their crispy haddock fish fry, which comes with a delightful salad option—a rarity that adds a healthier touch to the meal.
Desserts are not to be missed; the rich Oreo cake promises to satisfy your sweet tooth without overwhelming, making it perfect for sharing. With a warm atmosphere and attentive staff, SUBMASTERS is not just a meal; it's a community experience that beckons you to return time and again.
Fish Fry For 2 (SPECIAL)
Fish Fry For 2
2 fresh, hand battered 11 - 12oz. haddock. Each served with fries. coleslaw, tarter and fresh lemon.
Fajita Pizza
Your choice of fajita seasoned grilled chicken or sirloin steak with flame roasted peppers and onion, cheddar and monterey Jack cheese.
Baked Apple Pizza
Our new breakfast/dessert or anytime your in need of a sweet and delicious treat pizza! Baked apples with our brown sugar, butter and cinnamon sauce. Baked fresh to order and serve hot!
Margheritta Pizza
This is the one you have to try! Our California red sauce with blended oil and seasoning, fresh slices of provolone cheese, and hand chopped basil to create a truly tasteful experience!
Bacon Cheese Burger Pizza
Loaded with hand made burger, bacon, pickle, cheddar and monterey Jack cheese!
Dill Pickle Pizza
The newest trend in pizza with a butter garlic sauce added as a twist!
5 New Specialty Pizzas!
Just Desserts! (Fresh Made)
3 Layer Cherry Chip Cake
Chunky Monkey (Banana And Chocolate)
Fried Dough
A classic sicilian favorite
Chocolate Fudge Cheese Cake
S'mores Cake
N. Y. Cheese Cake
Apple Cinnamon Cheesecake
Deep Fried Oreos
Hot & delicious with powdered sugar.
3 Layer White Raspberry Almond Cake
3 Layer Funfetti Cake
Chocolate Oreo Cake
Coconut Cream Cake
Banana Split Cake
Moist banana cake layered a strawberry, chocolate and vanilla icing.
Red Velvet Cheesecake
Banana Foster Cheesecake
Strawberry Cheesecake
Reese's Peanut Butter Cheese Cake
3 Layer Strawberry Crunch Cake
Chicken Fingers (12 Pcs)
We use only the highest quality Tyson brand fingers. Extra bleu cheese for an additional charge.
Chicken Wings (50 Pcs)
Boneless Chicken Wings
Served with bleu cheese. extra bleu cheese for an additional charge.
General Tso's Boneless Chicken Wings
Chicken Fingers (6 Pcs)
We use only the highest quality tyson brand fingers. Extra bleu cheese for an additional charge.
Chicken Fingers (20 Pcs)
We use only the highest quality tyson brand fingers. extra bleu cheese for an additional charge.
Chicken Wings (10 Pcs)
Served with bleu cheese. extra bleu cheese for an additional charge.
Chicken Wings (20 Pcs)
Served with bleu cheese. Extra bleu cheese for an additional charge.
Chicken Fingers & Wings
Steak Subs
Steak & Sausage Sub (Small)
Seasoned ribeye steak with sausage, Swiss and American cheese.
Steak In The Grass Sub (Small)
Seasoned ribeye steak with spinach, Swiss and American cheese.
Steak & Sausage Sub (Large)
Seasoned ribeye steak with sausage, Swiss and American cheese.
Steak & Eggs Sub (Small)
Seasoned ribeye steak with Swiss and American cheese, topped with three eggs.
Steak & Cheese Sub (Large)
Most popular. Seasoned ribeye steak with Swiss and American cheese.
Steak & Eggs Sub (Large)
Seasoned ribeye steak with Swiss and American cheese, topped with three eggs.
Steak In The Grass Sub (Large)
Seasoned ribeye steak with spinach, Swiss and American cheese.
Garlic Steak & Bacon Sub (Small)
Steak sub on a garlic roll with Mozzarella cheese and bacon.
Steak & Capicola Sub (Small)
Seasoned ribeye steak with Swiss and American cheese, topped with fresh capicola.
Stinger Sub (Small)
Most popular. Seasoned ribeye steak and chicken fingers, with Swiss and American cheese.
Pepper Steak Sub (Large)
Ribeye steak, Mozzarella cheese, fried green bell pepper, and onion.
Steak & Capicola Sub (Large)
Seasoned ribeye steak with Swiss and American cheese, topped with fresh capicola.
Steak & Cheese Sub (Small)
Most popular. Seasoned ribeye steak with Swiss and American cheese.
Pepper Steak Sub (Small)
Ribeye steak, Mozzarella cheese, fried green bell pepper, and onion.
Philly Cheese Steak Sub (Small)
Steak, cheese, fried mushroom, onion, and peppers.
Philly Cheese Steak Sub (Large)
Steak, cheese, fried mushroom, onion, and peppers.
Stinger Sub (Large)
Most popular. Seasoned ribeye steak and chicken fingers, with Swiss and American cheese.
Steak Hoagie Sub (Large)
Steak and cheese with fried mushrooms and onions.
BBQ Steak Sub (Large 12")
Steak hoagie with bbq sauce and yellow American cheese.
Steak Hoagie Sub (Small)
Steak and cheese with fried mushrooms and onions.
BBQ Steak Sub (Small 6")
Steak hoagie with bbq sauce and yellow American cheese.
Garlic Steak & Bacon Sub (Large)
Steak sub on a garlic roll with Mozzarella cheese and bacon.
Taco Logs
New from Pizza Logs. Stuffed with ground beef, cheese and seasoned to perfection! Served with a side of sour cream.
Fried Bologna
Fresh sliced German Bologna
Johnnie Ryan Bottled Pop
In the traditional glass bottles
Macaroni Salad
Made fresh 8oz. serving
Greek Salad
Pasta, roasted red peppers, pepperoncini, tomato, cucumbers, and feta cheese in a zesty Greek dressing!
Pringles Potato Chips
Sahlen's 2 Hot Dogs, Side And Pop Meal
2 Sahlen's hot dogs served with your choice of macaroni or potato salad
Potato Salad
Made fresh 8oz. serving
Boom Boom Burger
Our hand made burger sub with a zesty Boom Boom dressing (Ken's original Boom Boom sauce, A light zesty kick and great on burgers!)
Italian Sausage Meal
-REAL SAUSAGE- Our finest mild Italian sausage link fresh from our deli case on a Dicamillos sausage roll with your choice of side dish.
Deli Sandwich, Side Dish And A Pop
Build your own! Made to order and FRESH sliced from our deli case on Dicamillos bread
Polish Sausage And Pierogi Meal
- REAL SAUSAGE- Our finest polish sausage link fresh from our deli case on a Dicamillos sausage roll and served with pierogis
NEW ITEMS! (updated 8/19)
Gluten Free Pizza
Build A Pizza! (Gluten Free)
Our cauliflower, gluten free pizza dough.
Traditional Cheese And Pepperoni (GF)
Grilled Chicken And Spinach (GF)
Tomato, Olive And Basil (GF)
Classic ingredients with our garlic and herb white sauce.
Cheese Burger Basket
1/4 lb. Served with fries.
Finger Fries & Pop Special
Four fingers with fries, Bleu cheese, and 20 oz. soda.
6" Sub With Fries & Pop
Comes with fries and a pop.
Every Day Special
Burger Subs
Cheeseburger Sub (Small)
Fresh hand-made burgers with yellow American cheese.
Bacon Double Cheeseburger Sub (Small)
Fresh made cheeseburger sub with bacon.
Bronto Burger Sub (Large)
Cheeseburger sub with bacon, bbq sauce and onion rings.
Bacon Double Cheeseburger Sub (Large)
Fresh made cheeseburger sub with bacon.
Cheeseburger Sub (Large)
Fresh hand-made burgers with yellow American cheese.
Bronto Burger Sub (Small)
Cheeseburger sub with bacon, bbq sauce and onion rings.
Fried Egg & Cheese Sub (Large)
Your Choice of Toppings.
BLT & Cheese Sub (Large)
All Fresh, Quality Ingredients!
Deli Club Sub (Small)
Oven browned turkey with Sahlen's Smoke House Ham, Provolone and bacon
Fried Egg & Cheese Sub (Small)
Your Choice of Toppings.
Pizza Sub (Large)
All Fresh, Quality Ingredients!
Sahlen's Smoke House Ham & Cheese Sub (Large)
Our Sahlen's Smoke House Ham With Provolone Cheese And Your Choice Of Toppings.
Meatball Parmesan Sub (Small)
Oven baked Italian seasoned meatballs, with sauce and fresh Mozzarella cheese.
Assorted Sub (Large)
Sahlen's Smoke House Ham, Oven Browned Turkey, Capicola with Provolone Cheese, and Your Choice of Toppings.
Baked Cheese Sub (Small)
Baked 3-cheese sub with peppers and mushrooms.
Sicilian Subs (Small)
Sahlen's Smoke House Ham, salami, capicola, pepperoni and cheese
Turkey Club Sub (Large)
Most popular. Fresh oven browned turkey with bacon and Provolone cheese,
Turkey & Cheese Sub (Large)
Oven Browned Turkey with Provolone Cheese, and Your Choice of Toppings.
Tuna Melt Sub (Large)
Our fresh tuna sub oven baked with cheese,
Salami & Cheese Sub (Small)
All Fresh, Quality Ingredients!
Capicola & Cheese Sub (Large)
Top Quality Margherita Capicola with Provolone Cheese, and Your Choice of Toppings.
Capicola & Cheese Sub (Small)
Top Quality Margherita Capicola with Provolone Cheese, and Your Choice of Toppings.
Tuna & Cheese Sub (Small)
All Fresh, Quality Ingredients!
Baked Cheese Sub (Large)
Baked 3-cheese sub with peppers and mushrooms.
Tuna & Cheese Sub (Large)
All Fresh, Quality Ingredients!
Veggie & Cheese Sub (Small)
All Fresh, Quality Ingredients!
Deli Club Sub (Large)
Oven browned turkey with Sahlen's Smoke House Ham, Provolone, and bacon
Meatball Parmesan Sub (Large)
Oven baked Italian seasoned meatballs, with sauce and fresh Mozzarella cheese.
Veggie & Cheese Sub (Large)
All Fresh, Quality Ingredients!
BLT & Cheese Sub (Small)
All Fresh, Quality Ingredients!
Turkey & Cheese Sub (Small)
Oven Browned Turkey with Provolone Cheese, and Your Choice of Toppings.
Hot Ham & Cheese Sub (Large)
Assorted Sub (Small)
Sahlen's Smoke House Ham, Oven Browned Turkey, Capicola with Provolone Cheese, and Your Choice of Toppings.
Pizza Sub (Small)
All Fresh, Quality Ingredients!
Hot Ham & Cheese Sub (Small)
Turkey Club Sub (Small)
Most popular. Fresh oven browned turkey with bacon, & Provolone cheese.
Sicilian Subs (Large)
Sahlen's Smoke House Ham, salami, capicola, pepperoni and cheese
Sahlen's Smoke House Ham And Cheese Sub (Small)
Our Sahlen's Smoke House Ham With Provolone Cheese And Your Choice Of Toppings.
Tuna Melt Sub (Small)
Our fresh tuna sub oven baked with cheese,
Salami & Cheese Sub (Large)
All Fresh, Quality Ingredients!
Classic House Subs
Beverages
Soda (2 Liter)
Five cent beverage deposit.
Johnnie Ryan Soft Drinks
A Western NY Tradition. Real cane sugar and glass bottles!
20 Oz.
Five cent beverage deposit.
Beef And Cheese
3 Cheese Quesadilla
Grilled Chicken Quesadilla
Steak And Cheese Quesadilla
Beef And Cheese Quesadilla
Quesadillas
Chicken Subs
Grinder Sub (Small)
Grilled chicken with fried peppers, mushrooms, cheese, and onions.
Chicken Pepperoni Sub (Large)
Breaded chicken fingers with pizza sauce, pepperoni, and cheese.
Chicken Bacon Ranch Sub (Large)
Moist grilled chicken, crispy bacon, cheese, and ranch dressing.
Chicken Finger Sub (Large)
Most popular. Breaded chicken fingers with choice of sauce.
Grilled Chicken Sub (Large)
Grilled and seasoned all-white chicken strips with cheese.
Honey Stung Chicken Sub (Large)
Grilled chicken, honey, bbq sauce, bacon, and Cheddar cheese.
Chicken Bacon Ranch Sub (Small)
Moist grilled chicken, crispy bacon, cheese, and ranch dressing.
Chicken Parmesan Sub (Small)
Breaded chicken fingers with pizza sauce and cheese.
Grilled Chicken Sub (Small)
Grilled and seasoned all-white chicken strips with cheese.
Chicken Parmesan Sub (Large)
Breaded chicken fingers with pizza sauce and cheese.
Honey Stung Chicken Sub (Small)
Grilled chicken, honey, bbq sauce, bacon, and Cheddar cheese.
Buffalo Chicken Subs (Small)
Strips of chicken sweet baby rays hot sauce and Bleu cheese.
Chicken Finger Sub (Small)
Most popular. Breaded chicken fingers with choice of sauce.
Buffalo Chicken Subs (Large)
Strips of chicken sweet baby rays hot sauce and Bleu cheese.
Chicken Pepperoni Sub (Small)
Breaded chicken fingers with pizza sauce, pepperoni, and cheese.
Grinder Sub (Large)
Grilled chicken with fried peppers, mushrooms, cheese, and onions.
Italian Wedding Soup
With meatballs
Tomato Basil With Ricotta Ravioli
Broccoli And Cheddar
Buffalo Chicken
Chunky Chicken Noodle
Soup
Dinners
Pasta Dinner
Penne pasta served with our classic Italian red sauce, two meatballs and garlic and herb bread. Try our parm style baked and topped with melted Mozzarella cheese!
Chicken Parm / Spaghetti
2 Italian style chicken cutlets served on a bed of spaghetti with garlic bread
Chicken Finger Dinner
Most popular. Five fingers come with fries.
Manicotti Dinner
New from our 5 star premium menu! 3 Creamy ricotta filled manicotti served with 2 meatballs, and garlic bread.
Fish Dinner
Battered haddock served with fries.
Meat Lovers Pizza
Chicken Finger Pizza
Served with hot sauce and a Bleu cheese base.
Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza
Grilled chicken and bacon with a buttermilk ranch sauce topped with cheddar, jack and Mozzarella cheeses.
Taco Pizza
Salsa, ground beef, tomato and black olives.
Italian Sausage Pizza
Sausage, pepper and onion.
Philly Pizza
Steak, mushroom, peppers and onion. Red or white sauce.
New York Style Pizza
Crispy corn meal crust with extra pepperoni.
Hawaiian Pizza
Red or white sauce with ham and pineapple.
Specialty Pizza
Party & Office Specials
Party Special
60 slices of pizza (one-free topping) 100 wings, and two 2-liter sodas.
10 6-Inch Sub, Salad For 10 & 2-Liter Special
10 6" subs, salad for 10 and 2-liter soda.
Burrito Dinner For 4
Fourth quarter pound burritos, family fries (serves four people) and a 2-liter soda.
Cheeseburger Dinner For 4
Four cheeseburgers, family fries (serves four people) and a 2-liter soda.
Pasta Dinner For 4
Penne pasta served with eight meatballs, garlic herb bread, and a 2lt soda.
6" Subs Dinner For 4
4 6-inch subs (triple thick subs not included), family fries (serves four people), and a 2-liter soda.
Chicken Fingers Dinner For 4
Sixteen chicken fingers, family fries (serves four people) and 2-liter soda.
Family Dinners
Wraps
Pesto Wrap
Half Tray Pizza With 20 Boneless Wings
Most popular. Comes with one free topping.
Full Tray & 50 Wings
Comes with one free topping.
1/2 Tray & 20 Wings
Comes with one free topping
Family Special
Half tray pizza, 20boneless wings, two large subs, and 2-liter soda.
Full Tray Pizza With 50 Boneless Wings
Comes with one free topping.
Pizza & Wings Specials
Healthy Choice
Tuna Sub
Our always fresh light chunk tuna!
Tuna Wrap
Light chunk tuna with your choice of veggies.
Pasta Salad
A taste of summer! Penne pasta with tomato, black olive, pepperoni, thin sliced provolone cheese and a light Italian dressing.
Oven Browned Turkey Sub
Our thin sliced turkey breast with your choice of fresh toppings,
Grilled Chicken Salad
Our seasoned and marinated chicken breast on a bed of fresh lettuce, tomato and red onion.
Build You Own Salad
Choose from the toppings below and we'll build you a salad the way you like it!
Veggie Wrap
Build you own! Choose your ingredients and we'll load them on!
Turkey Wrap
Thin sliced turkey with your choice of veggies.
Tuna Pasta Salad
Our light chunk tuna with penne pasta.
Jullianne Salad
Strips of turkey and ham with crisped lettuce, tomato and red onion.
Tuna Burrito
Served with cheese
Chicken Finger Burrito
Served with cheese
Beef & Cheese Burrito
Served with cheese.
Grilled Chicken Burrito
Served with cheese
Turkey Burrito
Served with cheese
Steak & Cheese Burrito
Served with cheese
Veggie Burrito
Served with cheese
Mega Burritos
Lunch Specials (anytime!)
Sub, Fries And Soda
Our 6" sub with Fries and a 20 oz. soda
Cheese Burger, Fries & Soda
Our fresh made 1/4lb cheese burger with fries and a 20oz. soda
Fingers, Fries & Soda
4 Tyson Chicken Fingers with Blue Cheese, Fries and a 20oz. Soda
Garlic Bread Sticks
We use a fresh dough baked to order with garlic butter, pamesan cheese and oregano. Served with dipping sauce.
Sweet And Tangy Wings!
You're gonna LOVE our new wing sauce!
Beer Battered Macaroni & Cheese With Bacon.
Beer battered mac and cheese with bacon! Absolutely Delicious!
NEW MENU ITEMS!
NEW!!! Build Your Own Sub
Build Your Own Sub
add any combo of any meats and toppings on a large sub
Sausage & Egg Sub (Small)
Italian sausage and cheese topped off with three eggs.
Sausage & Cheese Sub (Large)
Fresh Italian sausage sub with all your favorite toppings.
Royal Sub (Large)
Italian-style sausage sub with fried capicola and cheese.
Royal Sub (Small)
Italian-style sausage sub with fried capicola and cheese.
Sausage & Egg Sub (Large)
Italian sausage and cheese topped off with three eggs.
The Big Show Sub (Large)
Steak, sausage, capicola, cheese, mushroom, onions and pepper.
Sizzler Sub (Large)
Italian sausage and fried bell pepper, onion and Mozzarella.
Royal Supreme (Small)
Italian Sausage, fried capicola, fried pepperoni, and cheese.
Sausage & Cheese Sub (Small)
Fresh Italian sausage sub with all your favorite toppings.
Sizzler Sub (Small)
Italian sausage and fried bell pepper, onion and Mozzarella.
The Big Show Sub (Small)
Steak, sausage, capicola, cheese, mushroom, onions and pepper.
Sausage Parmesan Sub (Small)
Oven-baked sausage sub with pizza sauce and Mozzarella sauce.
Royal Supreme (Large)
Italian Sausage, fried capicola, fried pepperoni, and cheese.
Sausage Parmesan Sub (Large)
Oven-baked sausage sub with pizza sauce and Mozzarella sauce.
Sausage Subs
Pizza
Small Cheese Pizza Pie
Fresh and oven-baked to order!
1/2 Tray Cheese Pizza
Fresh and Oven Baked to Order!
Old Style Pizza
An old style bakery pizza with oregano, olive oil, parmesan cheese and italian seasoning.
Full Tray Cheese Pizza
Fresh and Oven Baked to Order!
Large Pie Cheese Pizza
Fresh and Oven Baked to Order!
White Pizza (2topping)
Our special garlic, butter and herb sauce!
Pasta Salad
Penne pasta, tomato, black olive, provolone cheese and a light Italian dressing
Greek Salad
Pasta, roasted red peppers, pepperoncini, tomato, cucumbers, and feta cheese in a zesty Greek dressing
Julianne Salad
Lettuce, tomato, onion, ham, turkey, and cheese.
Steak Salad
Ribeye steak, bacon and fresh lettuce, tomato, onion, and cheese.
Antipasto Salad
Lettuce, tomato, onion, ham, salami, capicola, peppers, mushroom, black olives, and freshly shredded Mozzarella cheese.
Macaroni Salad
Cold pasta salad made with macaroni noodles.
Taco Salad
Steak, beef, or chicken with lettuce, tomatoes, onion cheese, salsa, and sour cream.
Chef Salad
Fresh lettuce, tomato, and onion with strips of deli ham and Mozzarella cheese.
Grilled Chicken Salad
Strips of grilled and marinated chicken, lettuce, tomato, and onion with Cheddar Jack cheese.
Potato Salad
Cold dish made from seasoned potatoes.
Tuna Pasta Salad
Penne pasta, fresh tuna and mayo
Salads
Fries & Sides
Stinger Fries - NEW!
Our awesome fries topped with steak, chicken fingers and cheese!
Waffle Fries
Seasoned Waffle Cut Fries
Baked Pretzels
2- 7" inch pretzel logs
Fried Dough
A Classic Sicilian Favorite! Add Hot Apple or Cherry Topping for a Real Treat!
Onion Rings
Most popular.
My Girlfriend's Not Hungry.
Add a small french fry, pizza log and mozzarella stick to you order, because you know what's going to happen!
Bacon Cheese Fries
With Bacon and Sour Cream.
Deep Fried Oreo's
Hot and Delicious With Powdered Sugar.
Deep Fried Mushrooms
A Local Favorite!
Taco Fries
Served Taco Meat Salsa and Sour Cream.
Steak Cut Fries
Thick Cut
French Fries
Most popular.
Pizza Logs
Cheese and Pepperoni.
Bruschetta
Our 12" roll with butter, garlic, and herb spread topped with spinach, tomato, red onion and a double layer of fresh Mozzarella cheese! Simply delish!
Garlic Bread With Cheese
A Split Top Roll With Our Butter, Garlic and Herb Spread and Mozzarella Cheese.
Sampler
Includes two pizza logs, two Mozzarella sticks, two chicken fingers, and onion rings.
Cheese Sticks
Stuffed with Mozzarella Cheese.
2 Meatloaf Dinners
Each dinner consists of 2 pieces of meatloaf, mashed potatoes and salad.
2 Manicotti Dinners
Each dinner consists of 3 five cheese filled manicotti, 1 meatball. salad and garlic bread.
2 Lasagana Wrap Dinners
Each dinner consists of 3 five cheese lasagna wraps, meatball, salad and garlic roll.
2 Penne Pasta Dinners
Each dinner consists of pasta, o meatball, salad and garlic bread.
2 Haddock Fish Dinners
Two 11oz. Haddock fish dinners. Served with salad, fries and tarter sauce.
2 Chicken Finger Dinners
Each dinner consists of 5 chicken fingers, fries, bleu' cheese and salad
2 Ravioli Dinners
Each dinner comes with 2 huge 5 cheese filled ravioli, meatball,garlic bread and salad.